Water Heater Replacement & Installation in Columbus
Free, same-day estimates, next-day comfort, guaranteed.
Five Star Home Services offers top-notch water heater installation services in Columbus, OH, so you and your family can enjoy hot water on cold days in Columbus.
Got a Question? Get Answers in Minutes!
“Always able to get me in ASAP so my family of animals is safe in the heat.”
— Cooper Sandoval
“I would welcome them back and request them to do any repairs in the future.”
— Paula Whitney
“They do it the RIGHT way! I will keep coming back.”
— Claire Irwin
“My sump pump backup system was installed exactly as requested. Definitely recommend.”
— Ben James
“As a retired electrician, they get 5 stars in my book.”
— John Mason
“Their work is excellent and I couldn’t be more pleased with the results.”
— Vanessa Saunders
“My thermostat showed a drop of 7 degrees in a matter of 20 minutes.”
— Layla Burris
“Being a single mom, I felt very comfortable having them in my home.”
— Kim Harper
Tank Water Heater Installation
Back to Hot Water—Fast
Most Columbus homes have traditional tank water heaters. Traditional tank water heaters store hot water so it’s ready the moment you turn on the faucet. That means you don’t have to wait long for a hot shower or worry about interruptions during normal daily use.
But even when you’re asleep or at work, it’s heating your water. You pay for that, but you also get hot water immediately when you turn on your shower. For most people, that’s fine. Tank water heaters are either gas or electric. Which one works for your house depends on what’s already installed, how much hot water you use, and what the installation will cost.
Gas Water Heater Installation
Gas water heaters use a burner at the bottom of the tank. Natural gas from your home’s line fuels it. The exhaust needs somewhere to go, so a gas water heater installation needs a gas connection and venting. If your current water heater is gas, replacing it with another gas unit is straightforward since the gas line is already there. Switching from electric to gas means you’ll need a gas line installed, which increases the cost.
Electric Water Heater Installation
Electric water heaters have heating elements inside the tank. Two of them typically: one near the top, one near the bottom. Electricity heats the elements, and elements heat the water, so there’s no combustion, vent, or gas line. But operating cost is higher since electricity generally costs more than natural gas. Most Columbus homeowners see this reflected in their monthly bills. But keep in mind that if your household uses a lot of hot water, electric water heaters might not be able to handle the load.
Tankless Water Heater Installation
Tankless water heaters heat water on-demand. If you’ve ever run out of hot water halfway through a shower, a tankless system can help you there. Tankless water heaters last longer, too; about 15 to 20 years rather than the standard 8 to 12.
Credit-Friendly Financing Available!
From unexpected breakdowns to planned upgrades, we make it easy to afford your new water heater. All credit types are welcome. Our team will guide you through your financing options—without pressure and always in your best interest.
Our Promise To You
Why choose Five Star Home Services?
Five Star Home Services offers fast, reliable comfort backed by our plumbing and electrical expertise. With trusted service across every trade, we make your home repairs simple and stress-free.
Same day or it's free*
Done right or we'll make it right.
Trusted by neighbors. Guaranteed by us.
10% of profit goes to charity.
Multiple options always given.
FIVE STAR PROMIse
Trusted by neighbors, guaranteed by us.
Always Accountable
Done right or we'll make it right.
Fast Service
Same day or it's free.*
Service With Purpose
10% of profit goes to charity.
Transparent Pricing
Multiple options always given.Schedule with Five Star Home Services
Home comfort, as simple as 1, 2, 3!
With Five Star Home Services, getting help for your home couldn’t be easier. From heating and cooling to plumbing and electrical, our friendly full-service team takes the stress out of repairs. One call, one team, and you can relax knowing we’ve got everything covered.
Schedule in Minutes
Call or book online for fast scheduling.
Same-Day Arrival
Our expert technician arrives fast to diagnose the issue or provide an estimate.
Back to Comfort
Enjoy peace of mind with repairs done right the first time.
Serving Homes, Supporting Communities
When you book a service with us, you’re giving back too. A portion of the proceeds from every job goes directly toward supporting local community programs and families in need.
Hot Water Heater Installation & Replacement Reviews in Columbus, OH
See why Columbus trusts Five Star.
Columbus isn’t just where we work—it’s home. From the Short North and German Village to the family neighborhoods of Dublin, Hilliard, and Grove City, this city fuels everything we do. We’re proud to serve the families, friends, and fans who make Columbus such a great place to live, work, and stay comfortable. Here’s why we love our city:
Columbus Crew
We’re proud supporters of the Black & Gold! Just like the Columbus Crew, our team shows up ready to perform—day or night, rain or shine. Whether it’s cheering from the stands or providing emergency water heater repair before game day, Five Star Home Services keeps Columbus homes running strong.
Neighborhoods We Serve in Columbus
Our local team provides same-day water heater installation and replacement across Central Ohio. We proudly serve: Dublin, Hilliard, Westerville, Grove City, Upper Arlington, Worthington, Reynoldsburg, Pickerington, and beyond.
Giving Back to the City We Love
Through our Profit on Purpose mission, we invest 10% of every profit into local Columbus charities and community programs. Because to us, serving this city means more than keeping homes comfortable—it means building a stronger, brighter Columbus together.
Why Choose Five Star Home Services for Water Heater Installation in Columbus
Five Star Home Services handles water heater installation across Columbus and the surrounding areas.
-
Same-Day Estimates
Water heater dies on a Tuesday, you get an estimate that day, and a new unit installed on Wednesday. We don’t make you wait a week for hot water.
-
Proper Sizing
We size the unit based on your household, not what’s cheapest or easiest.
-
Licensed, Professional Installers
Our team handles gas line connections, venting requirements, and electrical work to code.
-
Financing Available
Water heater replacement isn’t cheap. We offer financing, so you’re not choosing between a new unit and paying other bills.
Columbus Hot Water Heater Installation & Replacement Reviews
Real stories from real customers.
From Columbus to Cincinnati, homeowners count on us for fast, dependable water heater installation and replacement. Read real reviews from customers who love our honesty, speed, and quality service.
“Nick was fabulous, knew exactly what he was doing, courteous, friendly and was very patient with 101 questions. Thanks Nick!”
Nick Schneider, Plumbing Drain Diagnostic
“Nick was VERY helpful and kind. He went above and beyond. It’s so refreshing to see such great rapport in times like now. Would definitely recommend!!”
Nick Schneider, Drain Diagnostic
Steve Monbeck, Plumbing Service Call
“I had a clogged main drain that kept the whole house from draining, James the drain specialist was absolutely amazing. He explained everything perfectly, he showed me what he was seeing and what I should be seeing. He gave me tips on how to prevent this in the future, he gave me tips so that I wont require further work, and he a great attitude the whole time. Highly recommending James/Five Star to family and friends. Couldn’t be happier with the service!”
James Ashley, Drain Diagnostic
“Chris Carr was absolutely amazing! My pipes had roots in them built up real bad and I was hoping we wouldn’t have to replace anything and him and his assistant and supervisor kicked ass and got my clean out taken care of and even gave us great tips to keep up on preventative care as well. He was very informative, fun to talk with and extremely personable, and even took care to clean up after the job super well! We’ll definitely be using them in the future!”
Chris Carr, Drain Diagnostic
“This was our second time using Five Star Home Care in Xenia, and they were just as great as the first. We had a clogged shower drain on a Sunday and were surprised to book an appointment that same morning! James Ashley, our technician, was professional, polite, and efficient. He cleared the drain, checked our pipes, and left the area spotless. Big thanks to Alexis for her help setting everything up. Highly recommend James and the Five Star team!”
James Ashley, Drain Diagnostic
“Chris did an amazing job! Our system was badly backed up just days after our home warranty expired. He and two other techs worked nearly 10 hours yesterday and Chris returned today for two more. What should’ve cost nearly $1,000 was cut in half thanks to the team’s generosity—and Chris’s hard work likely saved us from an $8,000 repair. Reminder: stay on top of roots in your lines—they can get out of control fast!”
Chris Carr, Drain Diagnostic
“Very professional, courteous, and knowledgeable. Unlike another company that showed up unprepared, they came within 24 hours, completed the camera inspection, found the break in 20 minutes, provided photos, and gave helpful repair recommendations. I’ll definitely use them again.”
James Ashley, Drain Diagnostic
“Chris did a great job! Very thorough, efficient, respectful – and, he of course solved our problem. We highly recommend Chris and Five Star for your plumbing needs.”
Chris Carr, Drain Diagnostic
“Hello, i had a great experience with Mr. Ashley, very polite clean well uniformed on time honest and very communicative and upfront about how it was gonna be approached and price was spot on now hidden fees and was done in no time, country needs more hard working class honest folks like James very appreciative and even asked him for card, serviced us on the lords day even on Sunday! Thank you very much and god bless him, highly recommended.”
James Ashley, Drain Diagnostic
Making A Difference Beyond Home Services
We don’t just fix homes— we help rebuild lives!
At Five Star Home Services, we’re more than just a home service provider. We believe families are the foundation of any home. This means that we don’t just fix homes—we help rebuild lives. Our mission? We serve those in need.
A portion of every job we complete goes toward giving back to those in need, partnering with local nonprofits, and investing in initiatives that strengthen our neighborhoods. We are dedicated to making a difference—the Five Star Difference.
With our roots growing deep into our communities, we wholeheartedly believe in Profit on Purpose—a commitment to using our success as the launchpad to create positive change throughout our service areas.
Your Purchase
With each purchase, you’re helping others in need.
Giving Back
A portion of our revenue is dedicated to giving back to our communities.
Community Change
These local non-profits carry out lasting community change.
When Do I Need A Water Heater Installation?
-
Your Current Water Heater Failed
Have you ever turned on the shower expecting hot water and got an ice-cold blast instead? Or worse, you come home to a flooded basement because the tank finally gave out. When your tank lets go, it can dump gallons of water onto your basement floor.
-
Your Water Heater is Over 10 Years Old
Just because it’s still working doesn’t mean your water heater is out of the failure zone. You can check the serial number to estimate the age of your water heater, since most manufacturers include the production date.
-
You’re Seeing Rust or Discolored Water
Rusty hot water means the inside of your water tank is starting to break down. Once that starts, there’s no going back. The tank will eventually leak. In older neighborhoods like German Village or Clintonville, with older plumbing, rusty water could also be coming from old pipes. A plumber can tell the difference for you.
-
Strange Noises From the Tank
If your water heater starts making rumbling or popping noises, that’s usually a sign that sediment has built up inside the tank. Over time, that buildup makes the heater work harder and can eventually lead to failure.
-
Not Enough Hot Water Anymore
Noticing how you used to be able to get through two showers without the hot water running out, but now you can barely get through one? Sediment buildup is reducing your tank’s capacity. You’re basically paying to heat water you can’t use.
-
You’re Upgrading to Save Energy
Older water heaters are energy hogs. A new high-efficiency or tankless model can cut your water heating costs. AEP Ohio may offer rebates for qualifying electric heat pump water heaters, but programs change. Even so, look into it before you commit to a new unit.
-
You’re Renovating or Adding Bathrooms
Adding bathrooms or finishing your basement? That means there’s going to be more demand on your water heater. Your current 40-gallon tank might not cut it anymore, so it’s better to upgrade sooner, before you finish renovating.
-
You Want to Switch Fuel Types
Tired of paying for electric heating and want to switch to gas? Or are you looking to get rid of gas appliances and go all-electric? That’s a new installation, and not an easy swap.
Frequently Asked Questions About Water Heater Installation
Everything you need to know before you buy.
The size depends on a few things: how many people are in your house and how much hot water you’re using. A good rule of thumb is 1-2 people need a 30-40 gallon tank, 3-4 people need a 40-50 gallon tank, and 5+ people need a 50-80 gallon tank.
Gas water heaters heat faster, while electric units are easier to install and more energy efficient. Our technicians will recommend what’s best based on your home’s setup and water usage.
Yes! We provide fast, emergency water heater replacement and installation throughout Columbus—often with same-day estimates and next-day service.
Most homeowners in Columbus spend somewhere between $800 and $2,500 for a water heater installation. Tankless systems usually cost more upfront, often ranging from $2,500 to $5,000 or more, depending on the setup.
Replacing a tank takes around 2-4 hours. If you’re just swapping one unit with a similar one (gas for gas, electric for electric), then it’s a bit more straightforward. Some installations take longer, especially in older homes with tight basement access and narrow staircases.
Water Heater Installation Experts You Can Trust
-
Need a new water heater? Five Star Home Services gets you back to hot water fast. We handle tank and tankless water heater installations for gas and electric in Columbus and the surrounding areas. Call Five Star Home Services or schedule your free estimate online. Columbus families trust us to handle water heater installation the right way.
Jump to Section
Peace of Mind with Five Star Protection Plans
Stay Worry-Free with Protection That’s Built to Last
Keeping up with your home maintenance shouldn’t be overly complicated. It should be easy. We offer impressive home maintenance plans designed specifically for you to protect your entire HVAC, plumbing, and electrical systems at competitive monthly price rates.
When you STAY PROTECTED with Five Star, you won’t have to worry about unexpected problems at inopportune times. With our plans, you can enjoy priority scheduling, exclusive savings, and more, knowing your home is always in expert hands.
We know it. You know it. But you also deserve peace of mind. So, kick your feet back and relax, knowing your home is protected by Five Star!
