Water Heater Installation & Replacement in Cincinnati, OH
Free, same-day estimates, next-day comfort, guaranteed.
If you’re looking to add a brand new water heater to a new build or replace an old failing unit in a historic home, Five Star Home Services has the solution. Tank or tankless, gas or electric, we can cover your water heater installation and replacement in Cincinnati, OH. Get in touch today, and our team of certified plumbers will get the water flowing as soon as possible.
Got a Question? Get Answers in Minutes!
“Always able to get me in ASAP so my family of animals is safe in the heat.”
— Cooper Sandoval
“I would welcome them back and request them to do any repairs in the future.”
— Paula Whitney
“They do it the RIGHT way! I will keep coming back.”
— Claire Irwin
“My sump pump backup system was installed exactly as requested. Definitely recommend.”
— Ben James
“As a retired electrician, they get 5 stars in my book.”
— John Mason
“Their work is excellent and I couldn’t be more pleased with the results.”
— Vanessa Saunders
“My thermostat showed a drop of 7 degrees in a matter of 20 minutes.”
— Layla Burris
“Being a single mom, I felt very comfortable having them in my home.”
— Kim Harper
Fast Water Heater Replacement & Installation in Cincinnati, OH
What Should I Look for in a New Water Heater?
If you’re ready for a new water heater installation in Cincinnati, OH, we have a few tips on what to look for in your new unit. Before signing on with a brand, keep the following in mind:
Serviceability
Put simply, a water heater that has tools for self-cleaning and easy-to-access components makes maintenance much easier. Anything that helps your technician do their job faster is less stress on you.
Fuel Type
Water heaters come in all shapes and sizes, and the way they draw power comes in several flavors. Electric options are more environmentally friendly, and gas options tend to be more economical.
Size
Different homes need different-sized water heaters. Going overboard or choosing a unit that’s too small can throw off the efficiency of your water heater. You could end up with cold-water bursts or higher energy bills as your heater tries to keep up. For example, a water heater installation in Cincinnati, OH, for a family of 4 or more would likely require a larger heater between 50 and 80 gallons.
Credit-Friendly Financing Available!
Whether it’s an emergency replacement or a planned upgrade, we make it simple to afford your new water heater. All credit types are welcome, and our team will help you choose the best financing option—without pressure or hidden fees.
Our Promise To You
Why choose Five Star Home Services?
Five Star Home Services offers fast, reliable comfort backed by our plumbing and electrical expertise. With trusted service across every trade, we make your home repairs simple and stress-free.
Same day or it's free*
Done right or we'll make it right.
Trusted by neighbors. Guaranteed by us.
10% of profit goes to charity.
Multiple options always given.
FIVE STAR PROMIse
Trusted by neighbors, guaranteed by us.
Always Accountable
Done right or we'll make it right.
Fast Service
Same day or it's free.*
Service With Purpose
10% of profit goes to charity.
Transparent Pricing
Multiple options always given.Schedule with Five Star Home Services
Home comfort, as simple as 1, 2, 3!
With Five Star Home Services, getting help for your home couldn’t be easier. From heating and cooling to plumbing and electrical, our friendly full-service team takes the stress out of repairs. One call, one team, and you can relax knowing we’ve got everything covered.
Schedule in Minutes
Call or book online for fast scheduling.
Same-Day Arrival
Our expert technician arrives fast to diagnose the issue or provide an estimate.
Back to Comfort
Enjoy peace of mind with repairs done right the first time.
Serving Homes, Supporting Communities
When you book a service with us, you’re giving back too. A portion of the proceeds from every job goes directly toward supporting local community programs and families in need.
Water Heater Replacement & Installation in Cincinnati
Proud to serve the Queen City—your comfort is our calling.
Cincinnati isn’t just where we work—it’s part of who we are. From downtown’s historic districts to the friendly suburbs, our city inspires everything we do. We’re honored to serve the homeowners, families, and local businesses that make Cincinnati such a great place to live and work. Here’s why we love our city:
Cincinnati Reds
Like our hometown team, the Cincinnati Reds, we believe in showing up strong and serving our community with pride. Whether it’s providing emergency water heater repair before opening day or keeping homes running all season long, we’re always ready to deliver Five Star service.
Neighborhoods We Serve in Cincinnati
Our local team provides same-day water heater installation and replacement throughout the Greater Cincinnati area. We proudly serve: Anderson Township, Mason, West Chester, Hyde Park, Blue Ash, Milford, Fairfield, Loveland, and surrounding neighborhoods.
Giving Back to the City We Love
Through our Profit on Purpose mission, we give back 10% of every profit to local Cincinnati charities and community programs. Because to us, serving Cincinnati means more than keeping homes comfortable—it means investing in the people who make this city shine.
Cincinnati Hot Water Heater Installation & Replacement Reviews
Real stories from real customers.
From Anderson Township to West Chester, families across the Queen City trust Five Star Home Services for fast, honest, and professional water heater installation. Read what your neighbors are saying about their same-day experiences and exceptional results.
“Nick was fabulous, knew exactly what he was doing, courteous, friendly and was very patient with 101 questions. Thanks Nick!”
Nick Schneider, Plumbing Drain Diagnostic
“Nick was VERY helpful and kind. He went above and beyond. It’s so refreshing to see such great rapport in times like now. Would definitely recommend!!”
Nick Schneider, Drain Diagnostic
Steve Monbeck, Plumbing Service Call
“I had a clogged main drain that kept the whole house from draining, James the drain specialist was absolutely amazing. He explained everything perfectly, he showed me what he was seeing and what I should be seeing. He gave me tips on how to prevent this in the future, he gave me tips so that I wont require further work, and he a great attitude the whole time. Highly recommending James/Five Star to family and friends. Couldn’t be happier with the service!”
James Ashley, Drain Diagnostic
“Chris Carr was absolutely amazing! My pipes had roots in them built up real bad and I was hoping we wouldn’t have to replace anything and him and his assistant and supervisor kicked ass and got my clean out taken care of and even gave us great tips to keep up on preventative care as well. He was very informative, fun to talk with and extremely personable, and even took care to clean up after the job super well! We’ll definitely be using them in the future!”
Chris Carr, Drain Diagnostic
“This was our second time using Five Star Home Care in Xenia, and they were just as great as the first. We had a clogged shower drain on a Sunday and were surprised to book an appointment that same morning! James Ashley, our technician, was professional, polite, and efficient. He cleared the drain, checked our pipes, and left the area spotless. Big thanks to Alexis for her help setting everything up. Highly recommend James and the Five Star team!”
James Ashley, Drain Diagnostic
“Chris did an amazing job! Our system was badly backed up just days after our home warranty expired. He and two other techs worked nearly 10 hours yesterday and Chris returned today for two more. What should’ve cost nearly $1,000 was cut in half thanks to the team’s generosity—and Chris’s hard work likely saved us from an $8,000 repair. Reminder: stay on top of roots in your lines—they can get out of control fast!”
Chris Carr, Drain Diagnostic
“Very professional, courteous, and knowledgeable. Unlike another company that showed up unprepared, they came within 24 hours, completed the camera inspection, found the break in 20 minutes, provided photos, and gave helpful repair recommendations. I’ll definitely use them again.”
James Ashley, Drain Diagnostic
“Chris did a great job! Very thorough, efficient, respectful – and, he of course solved our problem. We highly recommend Chris and Five Star for your plumbing needs.”
Chris Carr, Drain Diagnostic
“Hello, i had a great experience with Mr. Ashley, very polite clean well uniformed on time honest and very communicative and upfront about how it was gonna be approached and price was spot on now hidden fees and was done in no time, country needs more hard working class honest folks like James very appreciative and even asked him for card, serviced us on the lords day even on Sunday! Thank you very much and god bless him, highly recommended.”
James Ashley, Drain Diagnostic
Should I Repair or Replace My Water Heater?
Pulling the trigger on installing a new water heater vs. repairing your current unit is a tough call. Here are a few facts to help push you in the right direction.
- AgeOne of the easiest ways to identify a need for replacement is how old your current water heater is. If it’s pushing a decade of service, even if it’s still working well, you may want to consider going for a new model. It will fail eventually, as more time passes, those chances only rise.
- Repair CostsYour heater breaks down, and your plumber lays out the damage. If the work needed to keep it running costs more than half of what a newer system would cost, it’s a good call to go for a replacement. Repair costs will steadily mount, and upgrading to a newer, more efficient system can save you money down the line.
- LeakingTo the untrained eye, water near a water heater may not seem like the biggest issue. However, standing water is a symptom of a much larger leak problem. A cracked heater needs to be replaced and may pose safety risks in your home.
- Trenchless Sewer Line ServicesRusty patches and corrosion in or around your heater are cause for concern. This type of buildup creates weaknesses in your heater that will soon lead to larger problems and even more expensive repairs.
Making A Difference Beyond Home Services
We don’t just fix homes— we help rebuild lives!
At Five Star Home Services, we’re more than just a home service provider. We believe families are the foundation of any home. This means that we don’t just fix homes—we help rebuild lives. Our mission? We serve those in need.
A portion of every job we complete goes toward giving back to those in need, partnering with local nonprofits, and investing in initiatives that strengthen our neighborhoods. We are dedicated to making a difference—the Five Star Difference.
With our roots growing deep into our communities, we wholeheartedly believe in Profit on Purpose—a commitment to using our success as the launchpad to create positive change throughout our service areas.
Your Purchase
With each purchase, you’re helping others in need.
Giving Back
A portion of our revenue is dedicated to giving back to our communities.
Community Change
These local non-profits carry out lasting community change.
What Are The Benefits of Replacing My Water Heater?
-
Tech Upgrades
First, and most obviously, newer models come with better bells and whistles than their older counterparts. Swapping to a recent model can boost efficiency, give you access to smart features that can automate your perfect heating schedule, and reduce energy consumption. Instead of relying on an older model with a pilot light, a newer heater with electronic ignition can be more reliable.
-
Boost Home Value
If your home is on the market, having up-to-date heating technology can be a major benefit. Recently replaced water heaters are more likely to pass inspection and are more attractive to home buyers.
-
Fewer Repairs
Replacing an older heater with a new model restarts the repair lifecycle. A fresh unit isn’t going to cry out for repairs as often as the old unit you’re pushing to the limit. Fewer visits from the repairman mean more money in your pocket and more peace of mind.
-
Make More Space
We all wish our homes had more usable space. Dropping older, larger water heaters can free up valuable space; what you do with it is completely up to you! Newer models tend to be sleeker, less clunky, and friendlier when it comes to storage space requirements.
-
Reliable Hot Water
That old heater you’ve got banging around in the storage closet is far more prone to losing hot water than a brand new model. If you don’t want a cold-water jump scare in the shower, swap your aging water heater for a new one.
Gas & Electric Water Heater Replacement and Installation FAQs for Cincinnati Homeowners
Everything you need to know before you buy.
This depends on several factors:
-The size of your family.
-The number of bathrooms in your home.
-The number of appliances that require hot water.
-Peak water usage hours.
-The first-hour rating for storage water tanks (the number of gallons of hot water a tank can deliver in an hour, starting with a full tank).
Once you’ve got that information lined up, talk to your installation partner for the best sizing option for your home.
Gas water heaters heat faster, while electric units are easier to install and more energy efficient. Our technicians will recommend what’s best based on your home’s setup and water usage.
Yes! We provide fast, emergency water heater replacement and installation throughout Greater Cincinnati—often with same-day estimates and next-day service.
Quite a bit, actually. A run-of-the-mill heater could have a UEF rating of around .95, which means it’s almost hitting that 100% efficient mark with only a bit of energy waste. However, some Energy Star Certified products can get some truly high levels of efficiency (think 300%+). More efficient models will save you more money; it’s that simple.
There are a few options when it comes to deciding on the type of water heater you want:
Tank: Water heaters with tanks store hot water to pull as you need it. They can often heat water quickly and usually cost less upfront at installation time.
Tankless: Tankless water heaters use a heat exchanger to heat water as needed. They’re better if you don’t often pull hot water for multiple tasks at once (like showering and washing dishes simultaneously). They tend to cost more upfront.
Hybrid Heat Pump: These heaters combine tank and tankless strategies with both storage for hot water and a heat pump. They are very efficient but often produce condensation and require a more complex installation process.
Your installation team can help you go over maintenance routines you can complete at home; some common activities are as follows.
-Flushing the tank to reduce sediment buildup.
-Inspecting pressure relief valves.
-Checking anode rods for corrosion.
Jump to Section
Peace of Mind with Five Star Protection Plans
Stay Worry-Free with Protection That’s Built to Last
Keeping up with your home maintenance shouldn’t be overly complicated. It should be easy. We offer impressive home maintenance plans designed specifically for you to protect your entire HVAC, plumbing, and electrical systems at competitive monthly price rates.
When you STAY PROTECTED with Five Star, you won’t have to worry about unexpected problems at inopportune times. With our plans, you can enjoy priority scheduling, exclusive savings, and more, knowing your home is always in expert hands.
We know it. You know it. But you also deserve peace of mind. So, kick your feet back and relax, knowing your home is protected by Five Star!
